Study finds legal music far outweighs P2P on portable players
Posted on 06/07/06 01:13 by SeĂ¡n Byrne                             
Study finds legal music far outweighs P2P on portable players

From the time the first MP3 players such as the Diamond Multimedia Rio 500 hit the market, the music industry went strongly against these players claiming that their only use would be for listening to illegally downloaded music.  The RIAA even tried suing Diamond Multimedia back in 1999, but eventually came to a settlement.  Even Microsoft's CEO Steve Ballmer claimed that consumers carry more illegally obtained music on their iPods than what legal music they may carry. 

In a survey involving over 1,100 American people aged at least 12, the marketing research company Ipsos has actually found that 70% of music carried on portable music players have been legally obtained, contradicting what Microsoft and the music industry have been assuming up until now.  In the survey, an average of 44% of music is obtained from CD collections, 25% purchased from music download stores and a further 19% illegally obtained from file sharing services.  Of the music ripped from CDs, 6% of this music has been obtained from borrowed CDs, which the music industry would consider illegally obtained.  The average person carries about 700 songs on their music player.

Despite the popularity of the iPod, so far the study reveals that only one in five people actually have a portable music player, but this figure is growing at roughly 5% per year.  When the people were surveyed about their interested in portable video and radio, about 1/3 of those aged 12 to 24 were interested in portable video player and almost 1/2 were interested in having a built-in radio.  However, when people from the age of 24 to 54 were surveyed, the interest in portable video fell to only 1 in 6 people.  Thanks to RTV71 for letting us know about this news: 

A new study from marketing research company Ipsos Insight indicates that while file sharing may be down, it still constitutes a significant percentage of the music found on today's portable digital music players. Yet music downloads from legal services have eclipsed those stemming from P2P and other unauthorized sources. In fact, the study indicated that more than 70 percent of such music stems from legal sources, and that music download services are on the rise. The numbers show how far the industry has come from the days when CEOs would argue that "the most common format of music on an iPod is 'stolen'." If that view was dubious before, it's now outright ridiculous.

According to the study of more than 1,100 people, existing CD collections still provide the lion's share of music on portable players, accounting for 44 percent of such content. Download-to-own sales accounted for 25 percent of music on portable devices, while unauthorized file sharing accounted for 19 percent. While the music industry may be pleased, the study also indicated that 6 percent of music stemmed from users "ripping" CDs owned by others'”something the industry considers akin to raw piracy. With an average of 700 songs per player according to the study, approximately 175 songs per player have not been properly licensed or purchased in the eyes of the recording industry. (Of course, that number would be significantly higher if the RIAA's views on ripping legally acquired CDs were ever enforced.)

The full source article can be read here.

As consumers have the ability to download specific songs they like from a file sharing network, but are forced to buy full albums when they purchase a CD for one or two songs they like on the album, it would be interesting to see what the legal to illegal ratio of music that consumers actually listen to on their portable players.  For example, with the huge storage space on most of the iPods and other HDD based music players, most consumers simply rip full CDs instead of picking out their favourite titles, where as when it comes to file sharing services, consumers tend to prefer downloading by individual songs instead of by album, so while one may have a smaller collection of music obtained freely from P2P than what they have on CD, chances are that they may have more favourite songs in their P2P collection than in their entire CD collection.

Feel free to discuss about online music download services and stores on our forum.

Source: Ars Technica

Reactions
Discuss this article with your fellow community members! We appreciate your valuable input, but please keep the reaction policy in mind and make sure your reaction is constructive.
By heystoopid, Thursday 06 July 2006 07:29
"Very Interesting" to use the 'laughin injoke parlance' So many spokespeople, in both the RIAA/CRIA/ARIA/BPI/IFPI & MPAA have been telling a lot of big fibbers, embellished with very big meaningless ill defined numbers! , over the past 5 years or so! Oh well, too many lies, does not a fact make!cry
By gogochar, Thursday 06 July 2006 17:05
So, according to this article: 19%+(44*.06)~22%! That means that 22% of Americans are illegally obtaining music! I wonder how the RIAA thinks of 22-78 legality rate of music!
By themushroom, Thursday 06 July 2006 21:19
> such as the Diamond Multimedia Rio 500 You mean 300. The 500 was the next model after the 300. But back to the article. People rip the CDs they have, so 1-12 songs right there, so of course it's easier to use what you have (you bought it because you like it) than to go hunting for a digital copy online.
[edited by themushroom on 06.07.2006 21:21]
By Waethorn, Friday 07 July 2006 00:07
How was the information collected? Did they actually survey people first hand? With all the action of the RIAA and MPAA in the news do you really think people would tell the truth without fear that if they were doing something illegal, the RIAA/MPAA wouldn't just arrest them on the spot??!? Ok a bit far fetched, but really.... "70% of music carried on portable music players have been legally obtained". Unless a surveyee lies about it. The piracy and filesharing system is completely built on the idea of a lie. Nothing is free in life - there's always a catch. Work hard and BE ABLE to afford it. You'll be paying for life until you're dead, and then, so will the recipients of your estate. devil
Name: Email:



Your comment:

Receive notification on new comments?