Consumers win in battle for high def DVD standard?
Posted on 04/01/07 14:07 by Mike Kidd                             
Consumers win in battle for high def DVD standard?

An article in the New York Times reports that Warner Brothers is about to announce a new type of video disc that will have a movie recorded in both HD-DVD and Blu-ray formats. The new type of disc, called the 'Total HD', is cleverly designed to take the pressure off consumers who are currently undecided on which hardware format to adopt.

Of course this simply muddies the waters of corporate backing for the individual formats. Readers may be aware that Comcast and Walt Disney (plus Sony, of course) are both signed up exclusively to Blu-ray, whereas Universal is committed only to HD-DVD. However the move by Warner to release movies on Total HD neatly sidesteps this commercial battle and simplifies the choice of standalone high-definition for the consumer.

It could get even better for consumers, since the original patent application specified yet a third format on the one Total HD disc, that of standard DVD-Video. Thus consumers could buy a film at normal definition before upgrading their living room player, knowing that the same disc would play at authentic high definition in whatever playback hardware choice they made in the future.

The whole article is worth a good read, as it gives a useful history of the formats' development and competing corporate interests. It highlights the short-sighted moves of both camps which have resulted in the stalling of consumer interest in recorded HD discs in general.

Reactions
Discuss this article with your fellow community members! We appreciate your valuable input, but please keep the reaction policy in mind and make sure your reaction is constructive.
By Ginsu Victim, Thu 4 Jan 2007 14:41
I don't care. I've invested a lot in DVD, I'm not changing and neither is the general public.
By DukeNukem, Thu 4 Jan 2007 15:34
DukeNukemHow do consumers win? The disc will probably cost us $40. No way. I just bought "Anger Management" (widescreen) on DVD for $5.99. DVD was a blessing for us after all those years of snowy VHS quality. I have 650 retail DVDs and I'm not going to jump ship just yet. Sure I want Hi-Def, but it isn't the big jump from DVD that DVD was from VHS. There's too much money involved. New Plasma/LCD TV = $1000 - $3000 HD DVD/Blu-ray player = $500 - $1000 HD Movies = $25 - $35 each DVD succeeded for the following reasons: 1) You could use your existing TV. 2) People were already familiar with discs (audio CDs). 3) ONE format. Absolutely no confusion !! 4) Player prices dropped fairly quickly. 5) Studio support was unanimous. The only thing Hi-Def has going for it is #2 and #4. I've already made up my mind to go to HD DVD later this year. Please remember that we're the ones in control here, not the drive manufacturers and not the movie studios. THEY want OUR money !!! Smilie
By imkidd57, Thu 4 Jan 2007 15:56
imkidd57Good points, DukeNukem Smilie Just to mention that I was using the word "win" in a relative context within the group of people who already decided to go for a HD environment. I accept that for those of us happy with DVD-Video and its upscaling hardware advances, there is very little at the moment to tempt us out of the SD fold. Wink
By johnzap, Fri 5 Jan 2007 01:19
johnzapOK and what about pricing? HD-DVD + DVD-ROM discs already cost more than HD-DVD or Blu-Ray only. Probably another way for the studios to make more money. puke What's the hurry anyway? Let them battle it out and the advised consumer will pick up the spoils.
By DukeNukem, Fri 5 Jan 2007 14:32
DukeNukem@imkidd57 Oh, okay. Thanks for clarifying. @johnzap I agree. Let them battle it out. For once the consumer has all the time in the world and will benefit in the end. Smilie
By GristyMcFisty, Mon 8 Jan 2007 08:46
GristyMcFistyThis disc seems irrelavent now...see... http://www.cdfreaks.com/news/Dual-format-Blu-ray-HD-DVD-player-announced-by-LG.html
By DukeNukem, Mon 8 Jan 2007 19:17
DukeNukemIt would seem so.

Name: Email:



Your comment:

Receive notification on new comments?