EU launches anti-trust probe into Apple iTunes
Posted on 03/04/07 15:12 by Seán Byrne                             
EU launches anti-trust probe into Apple iTunes

With Apple refusing to allow its iTunes customers to purchase music from international iTunes stores, the European Commission has confirmed the opening of an antitrust probe into its music service and the way it sells music from the major music companies.  They allege Apple has signed agreements with the record labels which contain territorial sales restrictions that breach EU competition rules, where consumers can only purchase singles or albums from their country of residence. 

For example, the iTunes store in Britain charges ~$1.56 per single, where as iTunes stores in countries using the Euro currency charge ~$1.32 per single, however customers in Britain are not entitled to purchase music from the other cheaper European stores, despite Britain being part of the EU.  The iTunes music catalogue can also vary from country to country and consumers are only limited to the music available in their country's iTunes catalogue. 

Apple's Spokesman Steve Downing mentioned that Apple would like to offer a single store that covers all of Europe, but the limitations and rights set by the music companies and publishers prevent this.  Apple has been given two months to answer issues in the letter from the commission.  If Apple is found guilty of breaching the EU competition law, they could face hefty fines up to a maximum of 10% of the company's global annual turnover. 

The company is already being pushed by Germany, France, the Netherlands and Norwegian countries to change the rules imposed by its iTunes store's music upon its customers, such as the current restriction where iTunes bought music can only be played on an Apple iPod.  Norway has already declared Apple's move as illegal back in February, giving the company until October 1st to allow compatibility with 3rd party players or penalties.  However, Apple so far said that it is only willing to open its iTunes store music to 3rd party players if the major record labels made a change to their anti-copy measures. 

At present, EMI is the only major label to drop its anti-piracy measures, which means that its DRM-free music that will be sold initially through iTunes can be freely played or converted to play on any make or model of digital audio player, regardless what audio formats it supports.

Further info can be read in this ABC news report.

Reactions
Discuss this article with your fellow community members! We appreciate your valuable input, but please keep the reaction policy in mind and make sure your reaction is constructive.
By ClintB (guest), Tue 3 Apr 2007 15:40
I'm so sick of this EU crap. What a bunch of whiners. Seriously people, if ya don't want DRM, don't buy music with it applied. No need to have the government come in to babysit.
By Liggy, Tue 3 Apr 2007 17:44
LiggyYou did not read the newspost at all, did you? It's not about DRM but about not complying to EU law by not letting people buy their songs in other EU country's shops.
By fairyliquidizer, Tue 3 Apr 2007 22:03
Well said Liggy! It's also about the unfair pricing which means for example that people in the UK pay more than EuroZone countries. It has nothing to do with DRM at all. The guy from the EU said as much in an interview on BBC Scotland today. Hat's off to the EU. No doubt Apple will play the Microsoft card and claim it's a US versus the World thing and some people will be daft enough to swallow that and wave their star spangled banners for Apple. Me I welcome the regulatory pressure. The EU is a single market enshrined in law. If you trade with one you trade with all equally.
By rexroach, Tue 3 Apr 2007 23:21
we have been ripped off in the uk for years the usual record company trick is to do a UK exclusive album that had extra tracks so they can't be imported from the rest of Europe at a cheaper rate. The thing is the extra tracks are usually crap thats why they where not put on the album in the first place
By johnzap, Wed 4 Apr 2007 00:03
johnzapBah! The EU regulations suck! If they are so worried about the stupid songs, why don't they make it equally possible to purchase more useful things, like automobiles, on any EU country and not have to pay the extremely high taxes on the country of residence? If this is a free market, as they claim, why is it free for some things and not for others? puke
By klark_kent, Wed 4 Apr 2007 00:23
Just curious.. for all times Apple has been probed, investigated, threatened, etc. etc. what has actually changed? Not one dang thing.
By shaolin007, Wed 4 Apr 2007 02:32
shaolin007I bought an IPOD and took the piece of junk back. I couldn't get it to work and Apple made you use their sync ITUNES program to upload songs to it which caused issues with my pocket pc that also uses a sync connection. After several hours of trouble shooting I gave up. I was in disbelief that I couldn't just drag and drop a song to it since windows saw it as a HDD but no, they made the thing where you couldn't do something a simple as that. Personally, I don't see all the big deal about it anyways. It really puts a lot of restrictions on how you can transfer your music around. But hey, thats MO.
By fairyliquidizer, Wed 4 Apr 2007 11:00
This probe is targeting first and foremost the record labels (Apple is not the main target). The EU spokesman on the radio said that it was the restrictions imposed by the record companies that they are targeting.
By malimarek, Wed 4 Apr 2007 21:07
What about me. I am from Poland which supposed to be in Europe and we even do not have Itunes store dedicated for our country. Frown
By Icy Mt., Wed 4 Apr 2007 22:38
Icy Mt.I bought my sons inexpensive 1GB MP3 players. One Sandisk and one Creative. USB port plugin, XP drag and drop, no hassle. I bought 100% USA/RIAA legal music from music.msn until the hassle of burning to CD then ripping back to the hard drive as MP3 got to be too much. It was very easy for WMP to "lose" my licenses and render my songs unplayable. I was driven to the questionable legality of allofmp3.com by the simple fact that I could get DRM free music encoded at the quality I desired. Of course, getting higher quality for 1/4 the price didn't hurt devil When are these idiots going to quit punishing the people who actually still PAY for music?

Name: Email:



Your comment:

Receive notification on new comments?