FCC to adopt strict limits on digital video content to fight piracy
Posted on 23/10/03 00:22 by Seán Byrne                             
FCC to adopt strict limits on digital video content to fight piracy
Bane used our news submit to let us know that the US regulators will adopt strict limits in the coming weeks on what consumers can do with digital video content.  This will likely be a set of rules that can be adapted to broadcasts and physical media as a set of broadcast flags.  While consumers can still copy and backup 'flagged' content, they can only playback the content on their own equipment.  The regulators aim to reduce piracy and illegal Internet distribution by the implementation of this technology.

 

There is a major problem in implementing these broadcast flags as new DVDs that implement this flag cannot be played back on existing DVD players and most digital TV sets, thus consumers will need new upgrades or equipment to playback 'flagged' content.  Television-set set makers hope to implement the necessary equipment in their TV sets to support the broadcast flag on TVs from next year. 

Bane wrote:  It sounds like the limitations are justified. It sounds like it wouldn't limit "fair use" of the stuff though, so it's not going to limit my ability to make a copy and watch it in any room I want to. Only bad thing is that I'll need to buy new hardware.

U.S. regulators in coming weeks will adopt strict limits on sending digital television programs over the Internet to avoid the problems now plaguing the music industry, U.S. officials said on Tuesday.

The Federal Communications Commission will likely adopt rules that will allow programmers to attach a code to digital broadcasts that will in most cases bar consumers from sending copies of popular shows around the world, said the officials, who declined to be identified.

The approval, expected as early as next week, are intended as another step along the long road to higher-quality, crisper digital signals, which have been slow in coming because of worries about piracy, high-priced equipment and limited programming.

An agency spokeswoman declined to comment on when the five commissioners would vote on the issue.

Consumer advocates have warned that consumers will have to buy new DVD players if they want to play programs that have been recorded on machines that recognize the digital "flag." But agency officials stressed that that always happens when new technology hits the market.

"It will simply prevent consumers from illegal piracy, from mass distribution over the Internet, which is the problem with the music file sharing," Kenneth Ferree, head of the FCC's media bureau, said.

The music industry has been plagued over the last few years with consumers illegally sharing and copying songs over the Internet, which has led the recording industry to sue music downloaders for damages up to 0,000 per song.

Consumers will still be able to make unlimited copies of their favorite shows and watch them in various rooms of their homes, but they will not be able to send them over unsecured networks until protections are established, the officials said.

 

The US regulators are really asking for trouble if they expect over 50 million US DVD player owners to fork out for a new DVD player, just to support an anti-piracy feature!  It is one thing to change from VHS to DVD as pretty much everyone can see a clear advantage, but changing from one DVD type to another just to improve anti-piracy features will surely upset many.  This reminds me of the time when Sen. Fritz Hollings tried introducing a bill that would force all digital equipment to enforce copy protection measures.

Source: CNET News

Reactions
Discuss this article with your fellow community members! We appreciate your valuable input, but please keep the reaction policy in mind and make sure your reaction is constructive.
By Arc_Light, Thursday 23 October 2003 01:07
Arc_LightI think they should make DVD's/Music CD's that can't be played back on any hardware. This will ensure the honestly/integrity of the consumer to use this licensed media in the manner in which it was intended. Just think of the hours of enjoyment an entire family can derive from watching static and listening to white noise from their DVD as they watch it on their newly purchased DVD player! Mmmm. Mmm.. where do I sign up?
By chsbiking, Thursday 23 October 2003 02:19
The pirates will be able to crack the protection and open it up and play it on their old equipment. The pirates will have to buy no new equipment. The people following the law will be the ones forced to buy all the new equipment. So while they're out there buying new TV's and DVD players going broke the priates are at home watching unprotected media on the same equipement LOL LMFAO. Just like copy-protected CD's the people following the law most of the time can't get them to play right in their cars, and their computers but the pirates have no problem at all.
[edited by chsbiking on 23.10.2003 02:26]
By Kevin2, Thursday 23 October 2003 05:02
Just like the music, the movies are awful too. I dont buy them or download them.
By Crabbyappleton, Thursday 23 October 2003 06:36
CrabbyappletonNext the FCC will "allow" programmers to attach a code to digital broadcasts that will in most cases bar consumers from skipping over the 3 minutes of commercials every 7 minutes on your "favorite recorded shows" to be shown in every room in my house. Lets see....I am paying taxes to implement laws, that support technology, to cause me to have to buy new equipment, that will "allow" me to drive myself nuts! I knew I was going to go to hell. But I always thought I was going to die first. puke Frown
By TexasGuy, Thursday 23 October 2003 08:42
TexasGuyWhy the f* I have to buy new equipment? Does money grow on the trees? Let them buy me a new equipment. F*ers.
By spacegrass, Thursday 23 October 2003 20:05
They should quit selling discs and streaming content entirely. Instead, they should be selling Stereo/Video - Player combo units with the content directly built-in the device, with no external connections. That way, they can make it just a little harder for people to violate copyright laws, because you would have to get a new unit for every movie or album you wanted to see or hear.
By dentman42, Friday 24 October 2003 00:04
Fight it. If nobody buys the new equipment, it can't fly. I have no intention of buying a digital TV. There are millions of existing analog NTSC sets already in use, with more being sold every day. If we aren't willing to buy their copy protected digital garbage, they'll have to back down.
By 32ndRage, Friday 24 October 2003 06:39
First they got me to quit buying cds now they want me to stop buying dvds and new tvs? You know what I say? O.K. The only flag those greedy bastards better start thinking about is a white flag. People are not going to go out and buy all new tv set just to watch the new dvds. Imangine spending 10 grand on a new Plasma screen then they say now you got to buy this new one to watch the new Terminator 4 dvd. Ya right. As for the Pirating "they'll be back"
Name: Email:



Your comment:

Receive notification on new comments?