Microsoft claims its Windows Media DRM has no security flaw
Posted on 16/01/05 02:55 by Seán Byrne                             
Microsoft claims its Windows Media DRM has no security flaw

Recently there were warnings about opening WMA/WMV files from non trusted sources in case they exploit Microsoft's DRM to display pop-ups and attempt to install Adware or Spyware on the user's PC.  Now Microsoft has responded claiming that this is not a flaw in its rights management tool or media player.  They say that Windows XP Service Pack 2 will automatically block any attempted software downloads and those running earlier versions of Windows can also prevent automatic software downloads by upping their Internet Explorer's security level to high.

According to Microsoft, the pop-ups are no more risky than an inexperienced user landing on a similar website and being tricked into downloading dodgy content.  Panda software announced in an advisory warning about two dangerous Windows Media files, but can easily be spotted as they display a message thanking the user for the download and to click 'Play' to listen on the website.  Instead of playing the track, it actually downloads Spyware to the user's PC. 

As expected, Panda identified Overpeer as one culprit, a known company for fighting piracy by flooding P2P networks with fake content.  However Overpeer's chief executive office denied responsibility for delivering software to consumer's PCs, although they do admit their fake content does display a pop-up to divert the user to a legal music download store.  Another small company 'Protected Media' was also involved.  Microsoft announced that they will continue working on the problem and are planning to release an update that prevents Windows Media files from displaying a web page unless the user enables an option to do so.

Spanish security company Panda Software warned earlier this week that several companies are apparently using Microsoft Media Player's digital rights management (DRM) tool to fool people into downloading spyware and viruses. The existence of the files was confirmed by Harvard researcher Ben Edelman.

Microsoft responded Friday, saying that the security risk does not arise from a flaw in its rights management tool, although the issue is triggered by an apparently content-protected file. Content distributors can use Windows Media Player to pop up a Web page with information about a video or song, and in this case, that page was apparently loaded with automatic spyware download mechanisms.

The automatic downloads would be blocked on any computer running the Service Pack 2 release of Windows, Microsoft representatives said. People can also protect PCs running older versions of the operating system by turning up the security settings in Internet Explorer to "high," they added.

"There is no way to automatically force the user to run the malicious software," Microsoft said in an e-mailed statement. "This function is not a security vulnerability in Windows Media Player or DRM."

Read the full article here.

Even though Windows XP SP2 may prevent automatic downloads and pop-ups, there are still quite a lot of consumers out there running earlier versions of Windows or XP SP1.  Also as long as the content can display a webpage tempting the user to download a file, then there is a high risk of users getting infected.  For example if the page displays 'This media file requires a newer Windows Media codec, please download and install the following update and try again…"  Many inexperienced users would believe whatever the pop-up says and follow any given steps.

Interestingly, even though Microsoft encourages media companies to use its audio format and rights management software, it seems that they are getting well aware that consumers do not like having their content protected, especially when they encode it themselves.  For example in earlier versions of Windows Media Player such as version 9, copy protection was enabled by default for ripping CDs and a warning would be displayed if the user tried turning this option off:

However, once the user installs Windows Media Player 10 (Windows XP only) and goes back to the CD rip options, the 'copy protect' tick is gone:

Source: C|net News - Software flaws

Reactions
Discuss this article with your fellow community members! We appreciate your valuable input, but please keep the reaction policy in mind and make sure your reaction is constructive.
By icepax, Sunday 16 January 2005 13:59
Use Mozilla Firefox http://www.mozilla.com/ and ditch Internet Explorer altogether. Better yet, ditch Windows for Linux. Problems solved. You see, the solution is so simple. supergrin
By psychoace, Sunday 16 January 2005 16:50
I believe you can't play wma drm files on any other app other then Windows media player. Also the browser that pops up when you try to authenticate the file is part of the wmp app and can't be changed to anything like firefox.
By compu44, Sunday 16 January 2005 19:52
compu44Winamp will play DRM files, and other programs will too. However, you are right that media player will not load your default browser, it's always IE.
By warforpeace, Sunday 16 January 2005 22:39
warforpeaceWho plays DRM files? I know I don't Big Grin
By shimman, Monday 17 January 2005 05:34
i am preparing depart from ms windows just because ms & others are getting too aggressive about how i can use my own pc. speaking of xp sp2, it is very likely that ms intended to reduce the p2p network by limiting # of connections on one port. this will severly limit the speed of p2p networks. all those pop ups & security flaws are due to ms's intendtion to limit our rights to use pc as we wish i think mpaa, miaa, and other fake contents providers are worse than pirates & virus makers as they play innocent with governments backups
By Ranmacanada, Monday 17 January 2005 07:32
So this is just how like MS said they never stold the idea of windows? Money will buy you everythying in seems in the good old USA, I wonder how long till the European courts have a hay day with this and force them to fix this bug. Next thing you know all us windows users will be wanting Euro copies of XP just to get these fixes. Mind you, I agree with warforpeace, I don't know anyone who uses DRM. Tell me how I can use my content that I bought with my hard earned money. RIGHT. I bought it, it's mine, I will do what I damn well please with media.
By Nil Einne, Monday 17 January 2005 14:03
Altho I hate a lot of what MS does, the claim the SP2 limit on # of connections established over a certain time is to limit P2P is false. There are many good things about this change and most smart P2P software developers (eMule, most bittorent clients etc) recognise this and are working to make their software compliant. Only stupid developers insist it is bad and try to get users to to 'patch' their systems to remove the limit. The claim it severely limits the speed of P2P networks is also totally false. It does make you take slightly longer to get up to speed when you just start, but only slightly. It has no significant effects in the long term. There are a number of good articles explaining this change and I suggest you read them
Name: Email:



Your comment:

Receive notification on new comments?