CDFreaks Poll
Are you HD Ready? What's the resolution of your HDTV?
720p
1080i
1080p
I don't have an HDTV
Based on 1320 ratings

detail information

Posted by Tor Magne
Posted on 05/10/03 22:23
Number of views 7051
Menu
Reading Performance
 

Reading performance:


 

For these tests we will use Nero CD/DVD-Speed to read various CD and DVD's, including audio discs and DVD-media. As already mentioned in the introduction this drive sports a specified read speed of 16X for DVD's and 48X for CD's. 

Pressed discs:

For this test we used a pressed CD-ROM disc containing PlexTools v1.08 that is exactly 74 minutes long. Below you will see the produced result:

 

The drive reached its rated speed of 48X at the end of the disc with an average speed of 36,95X. How this compares to other 48X readers you may see in the table below:

Pressed
Discs

Average 
Read
Speed

Start
 Read 
Speed

End
 Read 
Speed

Seek
Times
 Random

Seek
 Times 
1/3

Seek
 Times 
Full

Plextor
PX-W4824A

34.47X

20.31X

45.48X

63ms

71ms

111ms

TEAC
CD-W540E

36.85X

22.08X

48.43X

88ms

102ms

229ms

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

36.95X

22.73X

48.11

84ms

93ms

155ms

Compared to the two other drives it's on par with the TEAC CD-W540 for reading and fits in between the Plextor PX-W4824TA and the TEAC CD-W540 for seek times, we can't complain as it reached it's rated speeds and seek times.

CD-Recordable Discs:

For this test we made a copy of the original PlexTools v1.08 CD. The disc we used was a Plextor 48X certified CD-R disc manufactured by Taiyo Yuden.

 

The reading speed for the CD-R disc backup is about the same as for the original with an average speed of 36,93X, again we presents an comparison table below:

CD-R
Discs

Average 
Read
Speed

Start
 Read 
Speed

End
 Read 
Speed

Seek
Times
 Random

Seek
 Times 
1/3

Seek
 Times 
Full

Plextor
PX-W5224A

35.68X

21.38X

46.87X

59ms

71ms

105ms

TEAC
CD-W540E

36.85X

22.08X

48.43X

88ms

102ms

229ms

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

36,93X

22,82X

48,15X

85ms

93ms

152ms

Nothing changes here, it's still between the two other drives for seek times, but marginally faster that the TEAC CD-W540E for reading.

CD-ReWritable discs:

Again we made a copy of the original PlexTools v1.08 disc, this time we used a plextor High Speed (10X) CD-RW disc made by Ricoh.

 

But for CD-RW discs the drive is locked at 40X reading and reached an average speed of 31.31X. Look below for a comparison table with two other 48X readers:

CD-RW
Discs

Average 
Read
Speed

Start
 Read 
Speed

End
 Read 
Speed

Seek
Times
 Random

Seek
 Times 
1/3

Seek
 Times 
Full

Plextor
PX-W4824T

31.45X

18.52X

41.53X

62ms

72ms

113ms

TEAC
CD-W540E

37.53X

22.12X

49.54X

99ms

96ms

303ms

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

31.31X

19.31X

41.13X

86ms

92ms

152ms

Again the seek times is between the other two drives, but the drive got outperformed by the other drives, the TEAC CD-W540E is beating it with a large margin since it's not limited to 40X reading for CD-RW discs.

Audio '? Digital Audio Extraction:

To test the digital audio extraction performance of the Lite-On LTC-48161H we again used Nero CD/DVD-Speed to measure the transfer rate. The audio disc we used is slightly larger than the disc used for the other tests, to be exact it's about 78 minutes long (77:56:58).

 

The drive supports reading audio at full 48X speed, and is topping out at a whopping 49,58X with an average speed of 37,61X. Below there's a comparison table:

Audio
Discs

Average 
Read
Speed

Start
 Read 
Speed

End
 Read 
Speed

Seek
Times
 Random

Seek
 Times 
1/3

Seek
 Times 
Full

Plextor
PX-W4824A

31.85X

18.94X

41.94X

61ms

74ms

111ms

TEAC
CD-W540E

30.98X

18.33X

40.82X

84ms

95ms

136ms

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

37,61X

22,78X

49,58X

83ms

96ms

163ms

This time it ends up as the slowest drives when it comes to seek times, but the seek times is still very good. But since the other two drives is locked at 40X for reading music it beats them with a long shot at raw transfer speed.

And as a last test we used Exact Audio Copy (EAC) to extract the audio to our hard drive. According to EAC the Lite-On LTC-48161H supports caching and accurate stream, as well as reporting C2 errors correctly.

 

Below is the results produced by EAC:

 

Burst mode

 

Secure mode

The drive performed as expected in the burst mode test and reached a top speed of 49,9X. But for the secure mode test it was only able to read at an average speed of 11,7X. Compared to other drives this is quite good:

EAC
Audio
Tests

Average
Burst
Speed

Maximum
Burst 
Speed

Average
Secure
Speed

Maximum
Secure
Speed

Plextor
PX-W4824A

30.3X

41.8X

9.7X

12.6X

TEAC
CD-W540E

29.3X

40.8X

10.1X

13.0X

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

35.5X

49.9X

11.7X

15.3X

Advanced audio '? DAE quality test:

Before we move on to testing DVD read speeds we will take a last audio test, this time we used the 'Advanced DAE Quality Test" feature in CD-Speed.

 

The Lite-On LTC-48161H is able to do on the fly copying at speeds up to 16X and probably more as well. It supports reading subchannel data and CD-Text as well as reading data from the lead in and lead-out. The drive is also good at reading audio since it reached a perfect score of 100.0

DVD reading performance:


 

Again we will use Nero CD-Speed to measure the reading performance, this time for various types of DVD discs.

DVD '? DVD-Video:

For our DVD reading performance tests we are going to start with a single and dual layered DVD video discs. While only 1X speed is required to watch DVD movies, it's useful to be able to read the discs at higher speeds if you're going to extract (rip) the content of the disc to your hard drive. Notice: Even if these discs contains DVD-Video they are identified as DVD-ROM discs for a reason or another, it's a disc issue and not a drive issue, we did several tests and this do not seem to affect the results of the tests in any way.

 

 

The drive was able to perform better than it's specified for and actually passed the 16X mark for the Single layer disc. The dual layer disc was read at 8X Max speed.

DVD
Video

Average 
Read
Speed
(SL)

Start
 Read 
Speed
(SL)

End
 Read 
Speed
(SL)

Average 
Read
Speed
(DL)

Start
 Read 
Speed
(DL)

End
 Read 
Speed
(DL)

Toshiba
SD-M1502

11.81X

6.52X

15.89X

Failed

Failed

Failed

Asus
DVD-616

11.80X

6.53X

15.53X

6.22X

3.45X

3.68X

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

12.14X

6.67X

16.25X

6.06X

3.04X

3.59X

It's very fast for reading the single layer DVD discs but is beaten by the Asus for the Dual-layer test. The Toshiba failed to recognize more than one layer of the disc and then can't be compared.

DVD '? DVD+R(W):

For this test we used an Arita 4X DVD+R and a Memorex 2.4X DVD+RW with about 4,4Gb of data. Below are the results:

 

 

While the drive did not read the discs at full speed it did read them without any problems. Let us compare the result with other drives and see how it compares to those:

DVD+R
DVD+RW

Average 
Read
Speed
(+R)

Start
 Read 
Speed
(+R)

End
 Read 
Speed
(+R)

Average 
Read
Speed
(+RW)

Start
 Read 
Speed
(+RW)

End
 Read 
Speed
(+RW)

Toshiba
SD-M1502

11.42X

6.32X

15.26X

11.41X

6.31X

15.24X

Asus
DVD-616

6.25X

3.50X

8.35X

4.45x

2.48x

5.95x

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

6.10X

3.48X

8.16X

6.13X

3.51X

8.19X

For a reason or another the Toshiba SD-M1502 is able to read DVD+R/RW discs at almost full speed and thus beating the other two drives. The Lite-On LTC-48161H beat the Asus on reading the DVD+RW disc though.

DVD '? DVD-R/RW:

For this test we used a Princo 4X DVD-R disc and a Ritek 1X DVD-RW disc filled with about 4,4Gb of data. Our test results are found below:

 

 

As we could see out from these graphs, the drive performed nearly the same with DVD-R/RW discs as with DVD+R/RW discs. Below is a comparison table:

DVD-R
DVD-RW

Average 
Read
Speed
(-R)

Start
 Read 
Speed
(-R)

End
 Read 
Speed
(-R)

Average 
Read
Speed
(-RW)

Start
 Read 
Speed
(-RW)

End
 Read 
Speed
(-RW)

Toshiba
SD-M1502

2.00X

2.01X

2.00X

3.26X

1.80X

4.35X

Asus
DVD-616

6.24X

3.49X

8.34X

4.44x

2.47x

5.94X

Lite-On
LTC-48161H

6.13X

3.50X

8.20X

6.08X

3.26X

8.02X

This time the Toshiba fell behind the other two drives. For the DVD-R disc the Asus is the winner, but for the DVD-RW disc the Lite-On is the winner.

But now it's time to head on to the most interesting part: Writing CD and DVD discs…

Want to submit your own review? Click here
Reactions on this item
Very good article I must say!
Great test !!!!!!
Very good the Advanced tests page is superb with all the copyprotections, even the
less used protections like Té¢ges,CD Cops
and the new SD2.9 !!!!!
Only missing is SF3 - I know it is hard to find a progam with this protections ;-)
Just be happy that I found tagé¨s and cd-cops protected discs :D
hey for the Blindwrite tests of SD2.8 and SD2.9 what were the Blindwrite configuration...meaning did you have "autoplay enabled???" or "enhance weak sectors??"" if not then this is the drive for SD2.9 without software enhancements:B
OOps, forgot to mention that in the review.

Autoplay: DISABLED!!!
Enhance Weak sectors: DISABLED!!!

Backup works perfect, even in picky readers as the Toshiba SD-M1502.
Could you add those new game tests to the review of Plextor PX-708A (DVD±RW)? I would love to know if it could handle the newer safedisc 2.9 and newer securom.

Fantastic review BTW. One of the best I've seen.
OC-Freak did test that and the information is available on the Plextor Forum. Here's a quote from what OC-Freak e-mailed me a while ago:

Tried blindwrite 4.5.7 today.

The sims: superstar - backup works in most drives (Lite-On LTD-165H and some others) but not in my default and picky test unit: Toshiba SD-M1502.

A perfect backup should work in the toshiba ;)

GTA: Vice city do still not work at all.
sd2.9040 is for SURE a no go with this combo drive
What do you think? Leave your comments!

Your message
:) :( ;) :r :d :B :X :c :o :g :+ :p :* :S

Your name
Your e-mail


Type in the code

Don't like to type in this code? Please register or login.
Related tags
A tag is a relevant keyword or term associated with or assigned to a piece of information (like picture, product, or video clip), thus describing the item and enabling keyword-based classification of information it is applied to. We use it to make searching our database easier and enable all our users to contribute to our database.

Add related tags
CD Freaks allows items to be tagged with objective specifications, no opinions or subjective descriptions. When your start typing our system will suggest tags, if this is what you mean, please use these first. Our system will also check for spelling mistakes and correct them to keep our database consistent. Finally tags are moderated by our team members.

    Related reviews/articles
    Visit the Forum
    Get the latest reviews via RSS RSS