CDFreaks Poll
An upscaling DVD player is worth the money?
Yes, my DVD movies look better
No, DVD quality is good enough
I don't buy content on discs anymore, downloads baby!
No, Blu-ray is the future
Based on 413 ratings

detail information

Posted by Dennis
Posted on 05/04/02 19:19
Number of views 8666
Menu
Writing Tests
 

The TEAC CD-W540E can write discs at a maximum of 40x meaning a whopping 6000kb/s. What does this mean in real terms? To answer this question we set up a basic write process using the latest Nero Burning Rom version (v5.5.8.0). We used the DAO (Disc At Once) method for writing the disc. In the screenshot below you can see the result:

Basic write test with Nero

Nope your eyes are working correctly... The TEAC CD-W540E only needs 3 minutes and 16 seconds to write the entire disc! We have seen some other reviews of the Plextor 40x drive and the Lite-On 40x drive on various sites but they all needed more time to finish the job. The TEAC drive is clearly the fastest writer we've see so far!

40x writing

When we compare the TEAC CD-W540E to other 32x recorders such as the Mitsumi CR-480ATE and the Lite-On LTR32123S the time difference is about 30 to 35 seconds.

We also did a 650MB test write with the latest CloneCD beta (v4.0.0.0 BETA 4) and below a screenshot. Notice the neat new feature of displaying the current data transfer and, in this case, writing speed:

Basic write test with CloneCD

The average speeds are now also mentioned in the CloneCD log window:

CloneCD Log File

Quality:

When writing as such high speeds it's important that the disc is written correctly. So therefore we did a check with Nero CD Speed to verify the written data. In the screenshot below you can see that the TEAC CD-W540E can read the disc without problems at full speed:

Transfer Rate - Back-up Disc

Transfer Rate - Back-up Disc And on the left you can see the actual speeds the TEAC CD-W540E reached. For the 40x write and quality test with Nero we used the disc that was provided with the writer. Here's the ATIP information:

  • ATIP: 97m 27s 57f
  • Disc Manufacturer: Mitsui Toatsu Chemicals, Inc.
  • Reflective layer: Dye (Short strategy; e.g. Phthalocyanine)
  • Media type: CD-Recordable
  • Recording Speeds: min. unknown - max. unknown
  • Nominal Capacity: 702.83MB (79m 59s 74f / LBA: 359849)

Comparing:

Next we did some more tests comparing the TEAC CD-W540E to some of our previous reviews. Please note that some reviews were done on different machines so the achieved writing times can be a little off. You can see the achieved results in the table below:

Table2

As mentioned before the TEAC CD-W540E is an extremely fast writer and in the table you can clearly see that the writer produces an excellent result and achieves the best time with every used write speed. The differences aren't even minimal but can be up to 30 seconds! These differences can be explained by looking at the way the TEAC writes the discs. Like mentioned before all drives use Z-CLV recording but the TEAC is the only drive to start writing at 20x while other drives start writing at 16x.

Writing Audio:

The next and final step was to check how fast the TEAC CD-W540E could write audio. Therefore we created a WAVE image and CUE-sheet of an audio disc with Exact Audio Copy and then loaded the CUE-sheet into Nero. We started the write process at 32x and checked if the write process would begin. The latest Nero version now luckily also has an option to check the actual write speed of the disc being written. Note that Nero calls this 'Read Speed': the speed in which the data is read from your harddisk:

Audio write test with Nero

We, of course, listened to the created disc for errors but the disc played perfectly. A surprise even since the disc we used was actually certified up to 16x writing (so therefore the disc didn't write at 40x) but Nero reported that the disc could be written at 32x. Strange since when we used the same discs with our Mitsumi CR-480ATE the maximum speed would be 16x as you can see in the screenshot below:

Audio write test with Nero

Conclusion:

So what can we conclude from all of the achieved results? Well simply that the TEAC CD-W540E is a great writer. Not only is it very fast, it can also write a lot of media (certified for a lower speed) at high speeds. In our tests we were surprised to see that the TEAC could write certified 16x discs ('That's Write', manufactured by Digital Storage Technology Co., Ltd.) at 32x. To verify this we even did another test and tried other 16x certified 'Traxdata' (manufactured by Prodisc Technology Inc.) discs. These could even be written at full (40x) speed! An excellent result indeed. A final conclusion we made is that, unlike the Plextor PX-W4012A, the TEAC CD-W540E isn't limited to 24x when writing audio. We could write audio at 40x without problems using proper media.

Want to submit your own review? Click here
Reactions on this item
Oh crap, why did I let you get this drive?:c

I also want it!!!

Great review, hopefully my next review(whenever that will be....) will also reach this quality level, although I have my doubts about that.:o
Great review G@M3FR3@K!


How is it possible that the included Feurio 1.63 and 1.64 support Teac540E?

Is there any way to support this writer under Feurio already?

How many DAE speeds has to choose?
Noisy?

It seems my next writer.

Feurio does not support the TEAC CD-W540E yet so we didn't test this. However support will probably be added soon enough (CD-W524E is supported already) with a Feurio drive update. The Feurio software is just part of the TEAC 'For Your Information' disc included with many TEAC drives.

The noise the drive produces is not too much but don't think it'll be quiet ;) What can you expect with 40x writing and 48x reading?

Thanks for the compliments guys :) Oh and ps: sorry OC... :g
About the buffer in Nero: Teac actaully has 8 MB buffer, but part of it is used by the drive itself. Unlike other manufacturers, which report complete buffer size, TEAC only reports 'usable' size.
In the review there is a reference in the Features section under the Write Method that says " "which writing methods the Mitsumi use" Should that not be Teac?

Also the warranty period of two years is only available in Europe correct?
Thanks jernej and pcguy99 : updated the article.
Again great article GF! ;)
The Teac CD-W540E can be found on Pricewatch.com for $95-US as of 4-9-2002
:4
Great review:

How noisy is it compared to say the 24x plex or 24x lite-on? [both are
reportedly "quiet" and
I guess vibration free].

I'm considering all 3 of these drives. I'm also going to a 1-drive soln for read and write to save a slot for something else. [I don't care about 48x read - infact I'd prefer a quieter and slower reader]

Main desire is "quality writing" for data. I'm even planning to run it "below max speed" to help out with quality burns.

Main concern on the TEAC is that its claimed to be noisy. And maybe it also vibrates [most vibrate when they are noisy] which could lead to write errors.

Neg: on the lite-on is reading no-perfect CDs is a problem. and maybe it does not last as long as the plex and teac.

neg: on plex [no gaming safe disc >2.5]

All of these drives are
within 30 bucks of each
other. So considering w/o regard to cost which would you get. It seems the 40x teac has the blood-line to give better 40x burns, but I don't care about "speed, rather quality" and would downshift to lower speeds.
Vibration free is highly desired.
but I don't care about "speed, rather quality" and would downshift to lower speeds.
========
sorry that should have read
but I don't care about "speed" that effects "quality" and would probably downshift to lower speeds for important backups.

Thanks.
Well the TEAC drive is far from quiet but I can say its main focus is quality as you can see by the various techniques it offers (Running OPC, Fine Focus Control, see [url=http://www.cdfreaks.com/document.php3?Doc=71&Page=3]page 3[/url]). However when it comes to backing-up SafeDisc 2 and above the Lite-On drive comes recommended followed by the Plextor and TEAC gets the third place. The Lite-On is the only drive that can copy SafeDisc 2 without problems. The Plextor has correct EFM encoding but has problems with SafeDisc 2.51 and the TEAC has problems with all SafeDisc 2 versions and therefore needs help with CloneCD's AWS.

If you don't care about maximum speeds and you want a drive that's not too noisy I would say go for the Plextor PX-W2410A. If you want a drive that's fast, reliable and produces quality at every write speed go for the TEAC. It will however by noisier than the 24x writers of course.

The vibration of the TEAC drive is no more than 24x writers and 32x writers if you have properly attached the drive.
oh... Crap :c i gotta get a 2nd JoB to Keep up with you guyz!

-Peace & Love :p
:c Just bought Teac 24X. Should I have waited for 40X? Does CloneCD support both? Thanks.
The copy of Nero v5.5 I received with my W540E OEM drive didn't recognize the drive. I had to download v5.5.8.2 from nero.com but when it recognized the drive, I wasn't allowed to choose it. Instead I got an error message saying I had to use the recorder the program was bundled with. Does anyone know how to solve this problem?

Can't wait to use these two products together as they both seem outstanding....
To: etr2
I think the Nero dl is buggy. I dl'd v5.5.7.2 for my 24X. Records OK but now get sys lockup when using the Wave Editor. Try uninstalling & reinstalling Nero 5.5, then dl 5.5.8.2 again. Good luck.
:(It didn't read copy-protected audio-cd's at all.I'll return the unit and go for the Plextor 40x instead.I have already returned on W540,because it started to return my cd's in small pieces.Crap!!
Hello,

Is TEAC CD-RW drive model CD-W540E provided with an digital/SPDIF output, besides normal analog one? On the left side of the analog audio output connector from the back panel is another one named "Strap S1". Is this connector for digital/SPDIF output? In the manual it says that S1 is "factory reserved"!? Anyone tried it?

What do you think? Leave your comments!

Your message
:) :( ;) :r :d :B :X :c :o :g :+ :p :* :S

Your name
Your e-mail


Type in the code

Don't like to type in this code? Please register or login.
Related tags
A tag is a relevant keyword or term associated with or assigned to a piece of information (like picture, product, or video clip), thus describing the item and enabling keyword-based classification of information it is applied to. We use it to make searching our database easier and enable all our users to contribute to our database.

Add related tags
CD Freaks allows items to be tagged with objective specifications, no opinions or subjective descriptions. When your start typing our system will suggest tags, if this is what you mean, please use these first. Our system will also check for spelling mistakes and correct them to keep our database consistent. Finally tags are moderated by our team members.

    Related reviews/articles
    Get the latest reviews via RSS RSS