CDFreaks Poll
What would you buy for $200 / EUR 200?
A cheap Blu-ray player
An expensive DVD player
Based on 774 ratings

detail information

Posted by Wendy Collins
Posted on 26/04/07 21:59
Menu
Authoring performance tests

 

DVD Authoring performance tests:


For these tests we used one MPEG 2 file of approximately 4 Gigabytes in size and one DivX file of approximately 700 megabytes in size and built a DVD compliant file set onto our review PC’s hard drive for each of our input formats.

MPEG2 to DVD test:

Our MPEG2 file was authored in 1 hour 6 minutes and 34 seconds.

DivX to DVD test:

Our DivX file was authored in 46 minutes and 25 seconds.

DivX Authoring and performance tests:


For this test we used one DivX file of approximately 700 megabytes in size and built a compliant DivX file with a menu structure.

From the source window we were able to add our file.

Using the chapter tool we added 20 chapters for testing purposes.

The menu structure was set at “Automatic” for our tests.

In the above screenshot we can see 3 menu pages have been created containing links to our 20 chapters.

In the above screenshot we can see our created menu displayed.

And in the above screenshot we finally have the links editor to allow us to manually edit the links to our chapters.

Now we tested our created “DivX with menu structure” in the simulation to make sure everything functioned as it should. The created menu system worked well and finding our created chapters was easy.

As a final test, we played the actual movie. The resulting quality was very good indeed and playback was flawless.

Our file was now ready to render and encode into a DivX file with a menu structure. As we can see from the above screenshot, our DivX file was rendered in 51 minutes and 6 seconds.

DVD Burning Tool:


In this test we wrote our authored DVD file set onto a single layer DVD+R media.

In the above screenshot we can see we are able to select our target drive and burning speed.

In the above screenshot, we can see our file set was built in 12 minutes and 41 seconds.

In the above screenshot we can see our disc image was created ready for burning to our DVD+R media in 3 minutes and 1 second.

Above we can see our disc was successfully burned at maximum speed (18x) but was burned much slower than expected, it took 12 minutes and 41 seconds to be exact. It should have been under 6 minutes with this drive. We tried to burn another disc, the result is below.

Once again we selected maximum burn speed (18x) and the disc was burned successfully, but once again very slowly. This time we watched the burn progress. At around 40% of the burn, the buffer was empty and the burning drive slowed down because of this. Clearly something is wrong with this tools buffer setting on Windows Vista (we were not able to test this under Windows XP). However we did check the file set could be burned with another burning application and this time we had no speed issues.

Set top player test:


We played our resulting DVD on various set top DVD players to check for compatibility and quality. The disc played without any issues and the picture and sound quality was excellent.

 

This concludes our TMPGEnc DVD Author 3 review.

Want to submit your own review? Click here
Reactions on this item
Where is the option to set chapters at set intervals like previous version of this software?
thanks
In the "cut editor" edit menu/chaptering tool.
or control+K
How is the menu creation? is it as generic and plain as the earlier versions or can you create a professional looking menu without the little window boxes for each track? can you place "play" buttons where you want them on the screen? can you rename the "play" buttons?
I have this program, and like it alot. BUT
One thing I hate is that when im burning several TV episodes to DVD, the names change from House S3E19 Act your Age to TRACK 2 or Title 2
And I have to manualy go rename them.

Can I make this keep the origianl file names?
As most users will very likely use the programme for authoring dvb video streams, it is important to keep the following in mind:

All files must be dvd compliant, esp. GOP sizes of > 15 for PAL andof > 18 for NTSC must be avoided. Otherwize, the built-in encoder really does a poor job: blocking where it has to intervene.
You may want to use the XDVD feature, of course, but there might be problems playing the discs in your stand-alone devices.

So, make sure your streams are compliant. If you are not sure, use Cuttermaran (option: dvd compliance) along with HC Encoder or QuEnc (necessary for the option to be enabled).
This message was edited at: 13-05-2007 23:38
TMPGEnc DVD Author 3
I found that when i was trying to go NTSC TO PAL By
the IEEE 1394 It was garble by starting the capture from the
monitor. When using play on the camera then start capture
on monitor it was good
Bob CBE Newcastle Australia
Q
have been taking some secne from some different movies using dvd shrink...i'm using dvd author 3 ..to make a disk... but does anybody know how make it where it will seperate chapters..(dvd author 3) in a track ... even though i have them set as seperate chapters it will play all of the chapters at one time can anybody help
This message was edited at: 07-06-2007 08:34
have been taking some secne from some different movies using dvd shrink...i'm using dvd author 3 ..to make a disk... but does anybody know how make it where it will seperate chapters..(dvd author 3) in a track ... even though i have them set as seperate chapters it will play all of the chapters at one time can anybody help
This message was edited at: 07-06-2007 08:34
Hi guys,

This software infact is a powerful tool for all newbies like me in terms of video editing. I find the software really helpful. But one thing is bothering me though -- the chapters i made in a single divx avi file during playback in a dvd player usually pauses for maybe hmmm a millisecond. It's noticeable though if your setting the movie to a 6min. interval chapters. Do you guys have any idea how to eliminate such??

Thanks and more power! ;)
This program has the best video quality output you can get, BUT it does not encode 5.1 audio and does not understand dual audio avi files.
Why it needed 1 hour to output a MPEG2 file into a MPEG2 VOB series? The old version needed just 15-20 minutes.

It might be that your MPEG2 file was a sort of DVB with long GOPs and less resolution (544 or 480 x 576 or x480) than the DVD specs (704 or 720).

Since all of my DVD players accept DVB streams in VOB files, I simply patch the first header then I author the DVBs as normal.

Whatz I like is the possibility now to have 2 audio streams and 2 subtitle streams - just perfect for ARTE.
Hi all
it appears in the latest version of Tmpgenc dvd author 3 they have removed the chaptering tool from the cut/edit menu. Any one else find this a pain and is there a way around it.
thanks
all of uu
people! the chaptering tool is still in the program!
it just doesn't have a dedicated button anymore. http://tmpgenc.
pegasys-inc.com
/en/lab/
tda3_chapteringtool.html
I can\'t make a dvd using TMPGEnc DVD Author 3. I have to save the image and use other software. I get the following popup.

\"There is no usable writing drive installed\"

I have a Sony dvd rw DRU-800 installed and works fine with other software. Has anyone had this problem and solved it?
Thanks in advance,
GR
Very good DVD-Author! Quality and everything! Just liked to know, when they starting support non-dvd sizes? like from DVB-T captured files.. 544*576 and 480*576... And when HD support will be available, i think that's pretty much i ever needed! :X
Sorry, two more things to wish - DTS audio output and audio normalize with RMS... :X
this software is very strong but have many problems that should fix it in next versions:

1-dosent support sub/idx format subtitles.

2-dosent support arabic encoding subtitles.

3-very slowly convert xvid to dvd .

but this program have a powerful feature : menu creation is simple and professional ,simulation its fantastic !
What do you think? Leave your comments!

Your message
:) :( ;) :r :d :B :X :c :o :g :+ :p :* :S

Your name
Your e-mail


Type in the code

Don't like to type in this code? Please register or login.
Related tags
A tag is a relevant keyword or term associated with or assigned to a piece of information (like picture, product, or video clip), thus describing the item and enabling keyword-based classification of information it is applied to. We use it to make searching our database easier and enable all our users to contribute to our database.

Add related tags
CD Freaks allows items to be tagged with objective specifications, no opinions or subjective descriptions. When your start typing our system will suggest tags, if this is what you mean, please use these first. Our system will also check for spelling mistakes and correct them to keep our database consistent. Finally tags are moderated by our team members.

    Related reviews/articles
    Visit the Forum
    Get the latest reviews via RSS RSS